Estimates of wear rates in metal bird bands, with applications for survival and movement models of marked individuals (2025)

Paul Sunnucks

2018, Journal of Field Ornithology

visibility

description

14 pages

link

1 file

Banding allows identification of individual birds, and many investigators use data from recaptured or recovered birds to infer population parameters, including survival rates, migration rates, and recruitment rates. Such analyses often assume that band loss is negligible, but wear rates have been found to differ markedly among different band sizes, band metals, and species in the few cases where wear rates have been determined. However, rapidly wearing bands may be over-reported in the published literature relative to slowly wearing bands for two reasons. First, researchers publish reports of rapidly wearing bands as a warning to other researchers, but may not publish reports of bands wearing slowly. In addition, sampling error may result in over-or underestimation of wear rates. At the extreme, underestimates of wear rates may imply that bands gain mass while worn (i.e., have negative wear rates), whereas extreme overestimates look like rapid wear; only extreme underestimates, not extreme overestimates, are unpublishable due to their a priori implausibility. Hence, the existing literature on band-wear estimates is likely upwardly biased relative to the true distribution of wear rates across species and band metals. Using routinely archived returned bands from the Australian Bird and Bat Banding Scheme for the period from 1963 to 2005, we estimated wear rates of bands applied to 173 species, five band metals, and 236 species/band size/band metal combinations. Band wear rates were generally well-explained by band metal and species functional group, i.e., birds of prey, waterbirds (shorebirds, herons, and ibises), passerines, waterfowl (ducks, geese, and swans), rails, seabirds, parrots, and other non-passerines, but some species had highly divergent wear rates compared to other species in their functional group. We also found that published estimates of wear rates were, on average, more rapid for a given metal type than determined from our analyses. We suggest that publication biases favoring publication of estimates of more rapid wear rates may drive the contrast between estimated wear rates in our analyses and published estimates.

Estimates of wear rates in metal bird bands, with applications for survival and movement models of marked individuals (2)

Sign up for access to the world's latest research

checkGet notified about relevant papers

checkSave papers to use in your research

checkJoin the discussion with peers

checkTrack your impact

Related papers

New longevity records of Black-headed Gull, with comments on wear and loss of aluminium rings

Benny Middendorp, Klaas van Dijk

2012

View PDFchevron_right

The utility of closed aluminium and butt-ended stainless steel leg bands for Australian Pelicans Pelecanus conspicillatus

Greg Johnston

Corella, 2014

Leg bands are one of the oldest and most widespread of methods used to mark individual birds for study, but different kinds of bands may infl uence results obtained. We compared recoveries from closed aluminium and butt-ended stainless steel leg bands deployed on Australian Pelicans Pelecanus conspicillatus between 1968 and 2004. All 64 recoveries from the 2123 closed aluminium bands deployed exhibited wear, whereas none of the 162 recoveries from the 12 427 butt-ended stainless steel bands deployed were worn. Closed aluminium bands resulted in 2.3 times as many recoveries overall, but half the recoveries within one year of deployment compared to butt-ended stainless steel bands. Only butt-ended stainless steel bands were recorded as “band only found”, suggesting they became dislodged from pelicans. This was confi rmed with pelicans that were simultaneously marked with leg bands and patagial tags. Together these data show that butt-ended stainless steel bands, while offering greater durability, result in less useful data than closed aluminium bands. A leg band that combines the durability of stainless steel bands and reliability of closed aluminium bands would provide a better proposition for the future studies of Australian Pelicans.

View PDFchevron_right

New longevity records of Black-headed Gull Larus ridibundus, with comments on wear and loss of aluminium rings

Klaas van Dijk

This paper documents new longevity records in Black-headed Gull. The world's oldest Black-headed Gull was observed for the last time on 21 March 2011 (photograph 28, page 20), 32 years, 8 months and 24 days after being ringed as a chick. Consequences of the use of poor quality metal rings are discussed as well. We confirm findings of an earlier study that aluminium rings should no longer be used to ring Black-headed Gulls.

View PDFchevron_right

Bird Skins in Museum Collections: Are they Suitable as Indicators of Environmental Metal Load after Conservation Procedures?

Torgeir Nygard

Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2003

To find out whether modern conservation treatments alter thelevel of metals in feathers, we analysed the content of 10metals in feathers before and after skins were washed withdetergent and treated with Eulan U-33 (a commonly usedpreservative at museums). Feathers of 31 birds of Goshawk Accipiter gentilis, Eagle Owl Bubo bubo, Feral PigeonColumba livia domest. and Common Eider Somateriamollissima were analysed.

View PDFchevron_right

Evaluation of different contour feather types for biomonitoring lead exposure in Northern goshawk (Accipiter gentilis) and tawny owl (Strix aluco)

A. Carballeira

Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 2012

View PDFchevron_right

Longevity estimates of Puerto Rican Birds

Wayne Arendt

1989

nowledge of the lifespans of wild birds is of both aesthetic interest and scientific importance. The accumulation of such knowledge can be accomplished almost solely through the bird banding process. Clapp et al. 11982,1983), Klimkiewicz et al. 11983), and Klimkiewicz and Futcher (1987) have recently summarized longevity records for North American birds through a survey of the Bird Banding Laboratory's records.

View PDFchevron_right

Species- and age-related variation in metal exposure and accumulation of two passerine bird species

Tapio Eeva

Environmental Pollution, 2011

We measured the concentration of several elements arsenic [As], calcium [Ca], cadmium [Cd], copper [Cu], nickel [Ni], lead [Pb], selenium [Se] and zinc [Zn]) in adult and nestling pied flycatchers (Ficedula hypoleuca) and great tits (Parus major) at different distances to a CueNi smelter in 2009. Feces of nestlings generally failed to correspond with internal element concentrations but reflected the pollution exposure, indicating an increased stress by removal of excess metals. The uptake of Cu and Ni were regulated, but As, Cd, Pb and Se accumulated in liver tissue. Pied flycatchers had generally higher element concentrations than great tits. The higher accumulation of As and Pb in pied flycatcher livers was explained by a more efficient absorption, whereas the higher Cd concentration was primarily due to different intake of food items. Age-related differences occurred between the two species, though both Cd and Se accumulated with age.

View PDFchevron_right

Quick methods for evaluating survival of age-characterizable long-lived territorial birds

Antonio HernandezMatias

The Journal of Wildlife Management, 2011

Survival is a key life-history trait in animals. However, most methods of survival estimation require substantial human and economic investment in the long term, particularly in species occurring in low densities, the case of most endangered species. An alternative to traditional recapture (CR) methods is estimation of adult survival based indirectly on either age ratios (AGR) or turnover rates (TOR) in territorial species. These 2 methods are applicable to bird species in which recruited individuals enter into the breeding population whilst still exhibiting the external traits that distinguish those animals from experienced adults. The main advantages of these methods are that survival can be easily estimated for all monitored individuals after just 1 or 2 breeding seasons and that disturbance to the species is minimized. The main constraints of indirect methods are that the assumptions are more restrictive than in CR methods, and survival estimates, although comparable between sites and years, may be biased. We used data from a long-term monitoring survey of 2 populations of the endangered Bonelli's eagle (Aquila fasciata), one in Catalonia (NE Spain) and the other in Provence and Languedoc-Roussillon (SE France). We evaluated survival estimates using the AGR and TOR methods and compared them with CR methods and provide suitable corrections for refining survival estimates based on indirect methods. In Catalonia (2002-2008), survival was estimated at 0.84 by CR methods (SE ¼ 0.047; n ¼ 25 radio tagged eagles), at 0.86 by the corrected AGR method (SE ¼ 0.011; n ¼ 558 bird à year), and at 0.86 by the corrected TOR method (SE ¼ 0.022; n ¼ 547 bird à year). In France (1999-2008), survival was estimated at 0.88 by CR methods (SE ¼ 0.040; n ¼ 45 darvic banded eagles), at 0.87 by the corrected AGR method (SE ¼ 0.015; n ¼ 443 bird à year), and at 0.87 by the corrected TOR method (SE ¼ 0.015; n ¼ 438 bird à year). All analyses suggest that females survive better than males and that individuals from the French population survive better than individuals from the Catalan population. We conclude that indirect methods, which should not be regarded as a substitute of CR methods, will allow wildlife managers and researchers to estimate accurately adult survival in a territorial species over a short period of time and to monitor survival across populations over large geographic ranges and over time.

View PDFchevron_right

Assessment of band recoveries for three Australian eagle species

Stephen Debus

Corella, 2015

Band recoveries to 2012 were analysed for the White-bellied Sea-Eagle Haliaeetus leucogaster (n = 11, recovery rate = 6%), Wedge-tailed Eagle Aquila audax (n = 55, recovery rate = 7%) and Little Eagle Hieraaetus morphnoides (n = 30, recovery rate = 9%) in Australia (for Wedge-tailed Eagle eastern Australia only). Juvenile/immature Sea-Eagles (n = 8) were recovered within 3.5 years (0-41 months, mean 13 months), 0-1824 kilometres (mean 268 km) from the banding site. Adults (n = 3) were recovered at the banding site; one notable lifespan was 19+ years. Of 60 Sea-Eagles wing-tagged in the coastal Northern Territory, 1978-1994, four (recovery rate = 7%) were juveniles recovered/resighted within 1-4 years, 30-90 kilometres from the banding site, whereas territorial adults were resighted on their territories over the ensuing year. Juvenile/immature Wedge-tailed Eagles (n = 55) were recovered 0-821 kilometres from the banding site (mean 130 km, 95% within 300 km), 1-72 months later (mean 11 months); one banded on Kangaroo Island was recovered on the adjacent mainland (13+ km across sea). Little Eagles (mostly aged as 'fi rst year or older' and unsexed) were recovered 0-2884 kilometres from the banding site (mean 219 km, 80% within 200 km), 1-311 months later (mean 60 months); notable lifespans were of 19-26 years, but average lifespan may be approximately fi ve years in the sheepwheat belt. Human-related mortalities, either deliberate (persecution) or accidental (e.g. collisions, interactions with infrastructure), formed a large proportion of the reported public recoveries of each species.

View PDFchevron_right

The fate of plastic leg rings used on geese and swans

Eileen Rees

Wildfowl, 1990

Engraved plastic leg rings have been placed on Barnacle Geese, Bewick's Swans and Whooper Swans to facilitate long-term studies o f individual birds within the different populations. The rate o f wear fo r Barnacle Goose rings was 0.23 mg/year which, on average, was less than 1 % o f the initial weight o f the ring. The mean rate o f ring loss was ju st 0.35 % per annum fo r Barnacle Geese, but different groups o f swans broke or lost their rings at rates varyingfrom 5.8% forfem ale Bewick 's Swans to 27.6% fo r male Whooper Swans with Vynalast rings during the fir st two years after ringing. In some cases, the type o f material used to make the swan rings affected their lifespan; Vynalast rings proved less durable than Darvic rings on Whooper Swans but there was no significant difference in the rate o f ring loss fo r Darvic and Vynalast rings on Bewick's Swans. Whooper Swans proved more likely to break or lose their leg rings than Bew ick's Swans, irrespective o f the material used to make the rings. The mean minimum lifespan recordedfor rings fitted to Bewick 's Swans was significantly shorter fo r males than females but there was no difference between the sexes regarding the lifespan o f Whooper Swan rings. Some individuals (predominantly male) were more likely to break or lose their rings than others. Different factors thought likely to influence the rate o f ring loss included the diameter o f the ring (larger rings had a lower survival rate), and the size and strength o f the birds.

View PDFchevron_right

Estimates of wear rates in metal bird bands, with applications for survival and movement models of marked individuals (2025)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 5912

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.